Buying Guides All Appliances

Best Hand Mixer for Cookie Dough and Holiday Baking: 3 Picks

The best hand mixer for cookie dough has a strong motor, a slow first speed and sturdy beaters. Our picks from Cuisinart, KitchenAid and Hamilton Beach.

KitchenAid KHM7210, Cuisinart HM-90S and Hamilton Beach 62682 hand mixers on wood kitchen counters next to bowls of dough and cream.

The best hand mixer for cookie dough has enough motor to push through butter, sugar and flour without stalling, a slow first speed so flour doesn’t fly out of the bowl, and sturdy beaters that won’t clog. For most holiday bakers that is the Cuisinart HM-90S, a 220-watt, 9-speed mixer that Cuisinart says can cut through a double batch of cookie dough and that comes with dough hooks and a three-year limited warranty. Pick the KitchenAid KHM7210 for a compact 7-speed mixer with heavy-duty Turbo beaters, or the Hamilton Beach 62682 if you bake a few times a year and want the lowest-cost option.

A hand mixer is not a stand mixer. It is the better tool when you want something light that lives in a drawer, makes one or two batches of cookies, whips cream for pie and mashes potatoes. If you are kneading bread every week or making triple batches of stiff dough, compare full-size models in our KitchenAid stand mixer comparison instead.

  • Real power under load. Wattage claims are not all measured the same way. Hamilton Beach explains that its “peak power” figure is the average maximum wattage the mixer may draw at start-up on high speed, while the marked rating on the mixer is the maximum stabilized power under load. Read the number together with what the maker says the mixer can handle.
  • A slow first speed. Cuisinart’s SmoothStart feature starts the beaters very slowly, with three low speeds, to keep ingredients from splattering. KitchenAid’s 7-speed mixer always starts on speed 1, no matter where it was set when you turned it off.
  • Beaters built for thick mixtures. Cuisinart’s extra-long beaters have no center post, so dough doesn’t pack into the middle. KitchenAid says its stainless steel Turbo Beater II accessories are made for heavy, dense ingredients.
  • The attachments you will actually use. All three picks include beaters and a whisk for whipped cream and egg whites. Only the Cuisinart includes dough hooks.
  • Storage. The Cuisinart and Hamilton Beach mixers both snap onto a storage case that holds the attachments, so beaters don’t go missing between holidays.
  • Warranty. In the U.S., Cuisinart backs the HM-90S with a limited three-year warranty and Hamilton Beach backs its hand mixers for one year.

Hand mixer picks at a glance

ModelBest forSpeedsPower (maker’s figure)What’s included
Cuisinart HM-90SThick cookie dough, frequent bakers9, with SmoothStart220 watts with automatic feedbackBeaters, chef’s whisk, dough hooks, spatula, storage case
KitchenAid KHM7210Compact mixer with heavy-duty beaters7, always starts on 1Not listed on the U.S. product page2 Turbo Beater II accessories, Pro Whisk
Hamilton Beach 62682Occasional bakers on a budget6, plus QuickBurst250 watts peak powerTraditional beaters, whisk, snap-on case

The Cuisinart HM-90S Power Advantage Plus is the one to buy if cookie dough is the main job. Cuisinart rates it at 220 watts and says an electronic automatic feedback system feeds in extra power when needed so the mixer won’t bog down under heavy loads. Its manual says it is powerful enough to cut through a double batch of cookie dough, or butter straight from the refrigerator.

  • Speeds: 9, shown on an LED display, with a one-touch speed control. Cuisinart’s guide lists speed 4 for mixing cookie dough and speed 1 or 2 for stirring in chocolate chips, nuts and raisins.
  • SmoothStart: the beaters start very slowly when you switch the mixer on, which helps keep flour and sugar in the bowl.
  • Attachments: extra-long beaters with no center post, a chef’s whisk, dough hooks for yeast doughs such as pizza and bread, and a spatula, all of which store in a clear snap-on case with the mixer on top as the lid.
  • Handling: a swivel cord for right- or left-handed use, a heel rest so the mixer sits flat on the counter, and a beater release lever.
  • Warranty: limited three years.

Cuisinart says not to use this mixer with nonstick cookware, so mix in a stainless steel, glass or ceramic bowl.

KitchenAid KHM7210: best compact hand mixer with heavy-duty beaters

The KitchenAid KHM7210 7-Speed Hand Mixer is a good fit if you want a lighter, simpler mixer that still handles dense batters. KitchenAid includes two stainless steel Turbo Beater II accessories, which it says are ideal for heavy, dense ingredients, plus a Pro Whisk for whipped cream and egg whites. Both are dishwasher-safe.

  • Speeds: 7. KitchenAid describes speed 1 for stirring in nuts and chocolate chips, speed 4 for mashing potatoes and speed 7 for egg whites and meringue. Its 7-speed use and care guide lists speed 3 for heavy mixtures such as cookie dough.
  • Soft start: the mixer starts on speed 1 every time you turn it on.
  • Cord and controls: a lockable swivel cord that clicks into either side of the mixer, digital speed buttons and a one-press beater ejector button.
  • Size: KitchenAid lists it at 8 inches deep, 6 inches high and 3-1/2 inches wide.

The trade-off is attachments. The KHM7210 does not come with dough hooks, and KitchenAid’s manual says the Turbo beaters are not designed for kneading bread dough. There is no storage case in the box either.

Hamilton Beach 62682: best budget hand mixer for occasional baking

The Hamilton Beach 62682 6-Speed Hand Mixer covers the basics for a holiday cookie swap or a pumpkin pie with whipped cream. Hamilton Beach rates it at 250 watts peak power and gives it six speeds plus a QuickBurst button that adds power at any speed.

  • Speeds: 6. Hamilton Beach’s mixing guide lists speed 2 for creaming butter and sugar and for most cookie dough, speed 4 for frosting and mashed potatoes, and speed 6 for whipping cream.
  • QuickBurst: press and hold for extra power, but Hamilton Beach says not to use it for more than two minutes at a time or the motor may overheat.
  • Bowl Rest: a groove that lets you rest the mixer on the edge of the bowl while you add ingredients. Hamilton Beach says never to use the Bowl Rest while the mixer is running.
  • Attachments and storage: traditional beaters and a whisk that store in a snap-on case. Dough hooks are not included.
  • Size: 9.2 inches high, 5.7 inches wide and 8.3 inches deep.
  • Warranty: one year in the U.S.

If your recipes call for very stiff dough or double batches, the Cuisinart is the safer choice. For a few batches of drop cookies a season, the Hamilton Beach does the job.

  1. Let butter soften first. Cuisinart suggests taking butter out of the refrigerator and cutting it into 1/2-inch pieces before you measure the rest of the ingredients, so it warms faster. It also says not to soften butter in the microwave unless the recipe tells you to, because melted butter changes the result.
  2. Start low. Begin on the lowest speed and move up as the butter and sugar come together. Use the speed your mixer’s guide gives for creaming and cookie dough.
  3. Add flour gradually. Mix it in on a low speed so it doesn’t puff out of the bowl.
  4. Scrape the bowl. When dough sticks to the sides, turn the mixer off and scrape the bowl with a rubber spatula, as Cuisinart recommends.
  5. Stir in chips and nuts last. Use speed 1 or 2.
  6. Give the motor a break. If the dough gets very stiff and the mixer slows down or feels hot, stop and finish the last mix-ins by hand with a sturdy spoon.

When the baking is done, clean the oven before the next round with our oven cleaning guide, and see our Black Friday appliance buying guide if you’re timing a bigger kitchen purchase.

Hand mixer buying checklist

  • A maker who says the mixer handles cookie dough, not just batters
  • A slow start or a low first speed to keep flour in the bowl
  • Beaters without a center post, or heavy-duty beaters for dense dough
  • Dough hooks, if you plan to knead pizza or bread dough
  • A storage case or bag so the attachments stay together
  • A cord that swivels or locks to the side you mix from
  • A warranty length you’re comfortable with: one or three years among these picks
  • A stainless steel, glass or ceramic bowl, not nonstick

Try the mixer on one batch before the holiday rush, so you know which speed your recipe likes and how the beaters lock in.

Tools and supplies mentioned

Cuisinart HM-90S Power Advantage Plus 9-Speed Hand Mixer

by Cuisinart

A 220-watt, 9-speed hand mixer with automatic feedback, three SmoothStart low speeds, extra-long beaters without a center post, a chef's whisk, dough hooks, a spatula and a snap-on storage case. Our top pick for thick cookie dough.

Fit check: Corded. Backed by a limited three-year warranty. Cuisinart says not to use it with nonstick cookware.

Check price on Amazon

KitchenAid KHM7210 7-Speed Hand Mixer, Contour Silver

by KitchenAid

A 7-speed hand mixer with two stainless steel Turbo Beater II accessories for heavy, dense ingredients, a Pro Whisk, a lockable swivel cord and a one-button beater ejector. The pick for a compact mixer that starts slow every time.

Fit check: Corded. Dough hooks are not included. This listing is the Contour Silver color; KitchenAid sells other colors of the same model.

Check price on Amazon

Hamilton Beach 62682 6-Speed Hand Mixer with Snap-On Case

by Hamilton Beach

A budget 6-speed hand mixer rated at 250 watts peak power, with a QuickBurst button, a Bowl Rest groove, traditional beaters, a whisk and a snap-on storage case.

Fit check: Corded. No dough hooks. Hamilton Beach says not to run QuickBurst for more than two minutes at a time. The U.S. limited warranty is one year.

Check price on Amazon

Frequently asked questions

Can a hand mixer handle thick cookie dough?

Yes, for most drop-cookie recipes. Cuisinart says its 220-watt HM-90S can cut through a double batch of cookie dough, and Hamilton Beach and KitchenAid both list cookie dough on their speed guides. Stir chips and nuts in on the lowest speeds, and use a stand mixer or knead by hand for stiff yeast doughs.

What speed should I use on a hand mixer for cookie dough?

It depends on the mixer. Hamilton Beach lists speed 2 for creaming butter and sugar and most cookie dough on its 6-speed mixers, Cuisinart lists speed 4 for cookie dough on the 9-speed HM-90S, and KitchenAid's 7-speed guide lists speed 3. Cuisinart and KitchenAid both say to stir in chocolate chips and nuts on the lowest speeds.

Do I need dough hooks on a hand mixer?

Only if you want to knead yeast doughs. Cuisinart includes dough hooks with the HM-90S for pizza and bread doughs. The KitchenAid KHM7210 and Hamilton Beach 62682 come with beaters and a whisk but no dough hooks, and KitchenAid says its Turbo beaters are not designed for bread dough.

Is a higher-wattage hand mixer always stronger?

Not necessarily. Hamilton Beach explains that peak power is the average maximum wattage a mixer may draw at start-up on high speed, while the marked rating is the maximum stabilized power under load, so the two numbers are not directly comparable. Compare speeds, beater design and what the maker says the mixer can handle as well.

Can I use a hand mixer in a nonstick pan or bowl?

Cuisinart says not to use its hand mixer with nonstick cookware. Use a stainless steel, glass or ceramic mixing bowl instead.

Sources

hand mixercookie doughholiday bakingelectric mixerwhipped creamdough hooks

Found an error? We correct mistakes promptly. See our corrections policy.