Best Slow Cooker for Thanksgiving Sides: 2 Picks That Free Up Your Oven
The best slow cooker for Thanksgiving sides is the Hamilton Beach 33969A for timing and travel, or the Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR 7-quart for the biggest batch.
The best slow cooker for Thanksgiving sides is the Hamilton Beach 33969A Set & Forget for most hosts, because it switches itself to WARM when the cook time ends or the food hits its target temperature, and its lid clips shut if you’re bringing a dish to someone else’s house. If you want the biggest single batch of mashed potatoes or stuffing and are happy to turn a dial yourself, the Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR 7-quart manual model is the simpler pick. Either one cooks or holds a side on the counter, which frees your oven and burners for the turkey, the rolls and the pies.
This is a research-based guide built from Hamilton Beach and Crock-Pot specifications and manuals plus USDA food-safety guidance, not hands-on testing.
How to choose a slow cooker for Thanksgiving sides
A slow cooker earns its spot on Thanksgiving by taking one dish off the stove and keeping it hot until dinner. USDA says a slow cooker cooks at a low temperature, generally between 170°F and 280°F, which is gentle enough to leave mashed potatoes, stuffing, green beans or sweet potatoes alone for hours. Look at four things:
- Capacity and fill level. USDA guidance (repeated on FoodSafety.gov) is to fill a slow cooker half to two-thirds full. Too full and food may be undercooked; too empty and it may overcook. Match the crock to the size of the batch, not the size of the party.
- Automatic switch to WARM. On Thanksgiving you’re juggling oven timers. A programmable cooker that shifts to WARM on its own keeps a side from cooking down while you carve.
- A lid that latches. If you’re the guest bringing the sides, a gasket lid with clips keeps them in the crock on the drive.
- Oven-safe stoneware. If you want to brown a topping at the end, check that the crock (not the glass lid) is rated for the oven, and at what temperature.
Slow cooker types for holiday sides compared
| Feature | Programmable with probe (Hamilton Beach 33969A) | Manual dial (Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR) |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 6 quarts, oval | 7 quarts, oval |
| Controls | PROGRAM (cook time), MANUAL, PROBE (target food temperature) | One dial: Off, Low, High, Warm |
| Switches to WARM by itself | Yes, at the end of the set time or when the probe reaches its target | No; it keeps cooking until you turn the dial |
| Lid | Glass with gasket and wire clip latches for transport | Glass lid, no latch |
| Crock in the oven | Crock is ovenproof; the lid must not go in the oven | Stoneware rated to 400°F, per Crock-Pot consumer care |
| Auto shut-off | Turns off after 14 total hours on | None listed |
| Dishwasher-safe crock and lid | Yes | Yes |
Best for most hosts: Hamilton Beach 33969A Set & Forget
The Hamilton Beach 33969A is a 6-quart oval slow cooker with three ways to run it. In PROGRAM mode you set a cook time and HIGH or LOW, and it switches to WARM when the time is up. In PROBE mode you push the included thermometer probe into the center of the food, set a target temperature, and it switches to WARM when the food gets there. MANUAL mode is a plain HIGH, LOW or WARM setting with no timer.
That auto-switch is what makes it the better Thanksgiving tool. Start the stuffing or a pot of mashed potatoes before the turkey comes out, and it won’t keep cooking hard while you carve. The probe also makes it a backup for a small bird or a bone-in turkey breast: Hamilton Beach’s manual lists a 6 to 7 pound turkey breast in the 6-quart model and calls internal temperature the best test of doneness for poultry. USDA’s minimum for all turkey is 165°F.
Hamilton Beach also designed it to travel. The lid has a gasket and wire clips on the handles, and the manual says the lid may be latched while you transport it. Power interrupt protection keeps it running through a brief outage, according to Hamilton Beach.
Know the limits before you rely on it:
- Hamilton Beach’s manual says not to use the WARM setting to cook food. WARM is only for food that is already thoroughly cooked. If you made a side ahead and refrigerated it, the manual says to reheat it on LOW or HIGH, then switch to WARM.
- The unit turns itself off after a total of 14 hours on, in any mode.
- The crock is ovenproof and microwave-safe, but the glass lid must not go in a microwave, conventional oven or on a stovetop. Never heat the crock empty.
- The US warranty is one year from purchase, per the manual.
Best for big batches: Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR 7-quart
The Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR is the classic manual slow cooker: a 7-quart oval stoneware insert, a stainless steel housing, and one dial with Off, Low, High and Warm. Crock-Pot lists it at 16.9 by 11.8 by 10.4 inches, with a dishwasher-safe stoneware insert and glass lid and a 1-year limited warranty.
It’s the pick when the batch is big. The extra quart over the Hamilton Beach matters for a double recipe of mashed potatoes or a large pan’s worth of stuffing, and you can still stay inside USDA’s half-to-two-thirds fill range. Crock-Pot’s consumer care team says the stoneware can go in the microwave and in the oven up to 400°F, so you can crisp the top of a sweet potato casserole before serving.
The trade-off is that nothing happens automatically. Crock-Pot’s consumer care team says Low and High are manual settings, not timed ones, so the cooker keeps cooking until you switch it off, and it gives a general guide of about 3 to 5 hours on High and 6 to 10 hours on Low depending on the recipe. On a busy Thanksgiving, set a phone timer to turn the dial to Warm once the side is done.
How to use a slow cooker safely for holiday sides
- Start with clean equipment and cold ingredients. USDA says to keep perishable food refrigerated until you’re ready to cook, and to store cut meat and vegetables separately if you prep ahead.
- Put vegetables in first. USDA notes that vegetables cook more slowly than meat and poultry, so they go on the bottom.
- Fill half to two-thirds full and keep the lid on while it cooks.
- Start it right away. FoodSafety.gov says not to set a slow cooker to start later in the day. A program timer that sets how long it cooks is fine; letting raw food sit before the heat comes on is not.
- Check with a thermometer. Casseroles and stuffing should reach 165°F, per FoodSafety.gov’s chart, and hot food held for serving should stay at 140°F or warmer.
- Don’t reheat leftovers in it. Colorado State University Extension says to reheat leftovers to 165°F in the oven, microwave or on the stovetop, then move them to the slow cooker to stay hot. Refrigerate leftovers in shallow containers within two hours; Hamilton Beach says not to put the whole crock in the refrigerator, because the contents take too long to cool.
CSU Extension also recommends setting the cooker on a dry, stable surface with at least 2 inches of space around it and plugging it straight into an outlet rather than an extension cord.
Slow cooker vs. buffet server vs. roaster oven
A slow cooker cooks a side and holds it. A buffet server or warming tray only keeps already-hot food warm for serving, so it’s the better fit once everything is cooked and you want a self-serve line. A roaster oven is effectively a second oven for the turkey itself. If you’re frying the turkey outdoors, a slow cooker or two can take every side off the stove. And if the main oven is still holding last year’s spills, give it a pre-holiday cleaning a few days ahead rather than the night before.
Thanksgiving slow cooker checklist
- Pick the crock by batch size and plan to fill it half to two-thirds full.
- Want it to switch to WARM by itself or travel with a latched lid? Choose a programmable model like the Hamilton Beach 33969A.
- Want the most capacity and the simplest controls? Choose a 7-quart manual model like the Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR, and set a timer to turn it to Warm.
- Use WARM only for food that is already cooked, and keep it at 140°F or hotter.
- Thaw meat and poultry first, start cooking right after you prep, and verify 165°F with a food thermometer.
- Check which parts can go in the oven before you brown a topping: the stoneware, never the glass lid unless the manual says so.
Tools and supplies mentioned
Hamilton Beach 33969A Set & Forget 6-Quart Programmable Slow Cooker
by Hamilton Beach
A 6-quart programmable slow cooker with PROGRAM, MANUAL and PROBE modes that switches to WARM when the cook time ends or the food reaches its set temperature, plus a clip-tight gasket lid for carrying a side to someone else's table.
Fit check: Use WARM only for food that is already cooked. Hamilton Beach says the glass lid must not go in the oven, and the unit turns itself off after 14 total hours on.
Crock-Pot SCV700-S-BR 7-Quart Oval Manual Slow Cooker
by Crock-Pot
A 7-quart oval manual slow cooker with LOW, HIGH and WARM on one dial, a removable stoneware insert and a dishwasher-safe stoneware and glass lid. The pick for the biggest single batch of mashed potatoes or stuffing.
Fit check: No timer: it keeps cooking until you turn the dial, so you have to switch it to WARM yourself. Crock-Pot's 1-year limited warranty applies.
Frequently asked questions
Can you make mashed potatoes in a slow cooker for Thanksgiving?
Yes. A slow cooker can cook or hold mashed potatoes so they don't need a burner or oven rack. Hamilton Beach says its WARM setting is only for food that is already thoroughly cooked, so cook or reheat the potatoes on LOW or HIGH first, then switch to WARM, and keep them at 140°F or hotter.
What size slow cooker do I need for Thanksgiving sides?
A 6- or 7-quart oval slow cooker handles a family-size batch of one side. USDA advice is to fill a slow cooker half to two-thirds full, so a 7-quart crock suits big batches, and a smaller batch belongs in a smaller cooker rather than a nearly empty large one.
Can I put frozen food in a slow cooker on Thanksgiving?
Not frozen meat or poultry. USDA says to thaw meat or poultry before it goes into a slow cooker because frozen pieces can spend too long thawing at unsafe temperatures. Hamilton Beach's manual also says not to use frozen, uncooked meat.
Can you reheat leftovers in a slow cooker?
Colorado State University Extension advises against it: reheat leftovers to 165°F in the oven, microwave or on the stovetop, then move them to the slow cooker to stay hot at 140°F or above. Refrigerate leftovers in shallow containers within two hours.
Can a slow cooker crock go in the oven?
Often, but check your model. Crock-Pot's consumer care team says the SCV700-S-BR stoneware can go in the oven up to 400°F, and Hamilton Beach says the 33969A crock is ovenproof, but its glass lid must not go in the oven. Never heat an empty crock.
Can I set a slow cooker to start later in the day?
FoodSafety.gov says not to. Start the cooker right after you finish prepping, because parts of the food can sit at room temperature long enough for bacteria to multiply. The Hamilton Beach 33969A's PROGRAM mode sets how long it cooks, not a delayed start.
Sources
- USDA FSIS: Slow Cookers and Food Safety
- FoodSafety.gov: Warm Up with a Safely Slow-Cooked Meal
- FoodSafety.gov: Safe Minimum Internal Temperature Chart
- Colorado State University Extension: Crockpot and Slow Cooker Food Safety
- Hamilton Beach: Set & Forget 6 Qt. Programmable Slow Cooker (33969A)
- Hamilton Beach: Programmable Slow Cooker Use and Care Guide, models 33863, 33966, 33969 (PDF)
- Crock-Pot: Manual 7-Quart Slow Cooker, Stainless Steel (SCV700-S-BR)